We obsess over our client experience—and it shows

It’s not just rave reviews. It’s relationships. Our team has been buying and selling homes in New Albany and surrounding neighborhoods for over two decades. We have been very fortunate to help more than 2,000 great families through the real estate process. Here is what they have to say about working with our team.

All Reviews 5.0google logoGoogle 5.0zillow logoZillow 5.0
Overall Rating
5.0 428 reviews
Brenda Hunt Avatar
Brenda Hunt
We have had the pleasure of knowing Rob for many years and entrusted him in both the purchase and sell of our home. To say that we are pleased would be an understatement. Rob and his team were wonderful to work with and would highly recommend them for any of your real estate needs.
read more
09/01/2025
David Cahill Avatar
David Cahill
Rob did a phenomenal job selling our house!!! We sold way above list price, and sold in a day. He is extremely flexible, willing to answer all of our questions, is very confident, and is honest and trustworthy.
read more
29/12/2024
Brett Evans Avatar
Brett Evans
We had the pleasure of being represented by Kandis Hall in both buying and selling. She demonstrated expansive market knowledge, had tremendous communication and was supportive all the way through the process. She also negotiated the sale price of our house well over asking in just days of listing. We cannot recommend her enough.
read more
28/12/2024
Rebecca McDavid Avatar
Rebecca McDavid
Tracy has been awesome! She responds to texts quickly. She understands and explains the home buying and selling process very clearly. Would recommend her to anyone on the house hunt.
read more
26/12/2024
Summiyah Nasir Avatar
Summiyah Nasir
We are so grateful to Kauser for finding us a beautiful home! We had been in the market for two years and it was just getting harder to find what we wanted. But Thankfully we found Kauser!!! She was amazing, knowledgeable, on top of her game and always available to accommodate us. We highly recommend her. We not only found a new home but a great friend. We are so grateful❤️❤️
read more
18/12/2024
Reese Avatar
Reese
I am very happy that we chose Heather Graham from New Albany Realty as our realtor. From the start I knew we made a good choice as she was very responsive and flexible and took a lot of time to listen to what we wanted from a home and helped us find the perfect place. Heather provides a personal touch and connection that you won’t get with just any realtor. Thank you Heather for finding our new home!
read more
12/12/2024
Claire Horn Avatar
Claire Horn
We cannot say enough positive things about Kandis Hall when it comes to both selling and buying a home. We have lived in New Albany for about five years and got Kandis' name through friends, and we are so glad we did. Not only was Kandis able to find us our dream home off market but she was so easy to work with when we sold our home. We have two young children so thinking about the selling and open houses made us anxious but Kandis put our minds at ease. She made the process seamless from start to finish. Kandis truly goes above and beyond for her client's in every way. Kandis worked through every step of the selling process with us and never missed a beat. It is hard to pinpoint a favorite thing about Kandis. She is knowledgeable, kind, hardworking, and responsive. If you are looking to buy or sell a home in New Albany or anywhere, you should make Kandis Hall your first call!
read more
10/12/2024
Ram Patnaik Avatar
Ram Patnaik
As a first-time seller, finding a trustworthy realtor can be challenging. Scott Siebenaler stood out with his transparency and honest approach, avoiding any overselling. I’m extremely pleased with the services he provided, making the selling process seamless. Highly recommend!
read more
23/11/2024
Mary Alice Ackerman Avatar
Mary Alice Ackerman
Our family recently relocated from Los Angeles, California, to New Albany, and we couldn’t have done it without Kandis Hall. Kandis was truly a guardian angel throughout the entire process. She not only helped us find our dream home before it even hit the market but also worked tirelessly to ensure we got the best deal and saw everything through to a smooth closure. If you’re looking for a realtor in the Columbus area, I cannot recommend Kandis enough—10/10! Thank you, Kandis, for making this transition so seamless. We are beyond happy in our new home!
read more
22/11/2024
Terry Cahill Avatar
Terry Cahill
We have been so happy working with Andrea! This has been a long process for us as we weren’t quite sure where we wanted to be and what type of house we wanted to buy. Andrea showed infinite patience and always responded to any question promptly! She helped us negotiate through a change of mind purchase and was with us every step of the way until we closed on our new house! We can’t thank her enough for aiding us through this process.
read more
09/10/2024
media thumbnail 0
Lauren Tetidrick Avatar
Lauren Tetidrick
Working with Lauren Davie to sell our home was a seamless experience. Our situation was something that needed to be handled with professionalism and great care, and she was outstanding with both. She provided great data for comps, got us a great offer over our original plans, and ensured that all communication was timely and done right. Thank you, Lauren for being such an inclusive; knowledgeable; and most importantly kind real estate professional. The best part: we trusted her. Thank you again!
read more
08/10/2024
Leslie Kemelgor Avatar
Leslie Kemelgor
I am incredibly grateful for the outstanding service provided by real estate consultant Lauren Davie! She recently helped me sell my home and find a new one, and the entire experience was exceptional. From our first meeting, it was clear that she genuinely cares about her clients. Her attention to detail and proactive approach made selling my home seamless. She provided invaluable advice and figuratively held my hand throughout the entire process. When it came to finding my new home, Lauren truly went above and beyond. She listened to my needs and preferences to help me find the perfect fit. She was always available to answer my questions and offered support every step of the way. Her dedication, professionalism, trustworthiness, and warm personality made what could have been a stressful process feel easy and enjoyable. If you’re looking for a realtor who truly cares, and will advocate for you throughout every phase of the journey, look no further than Lauren Davie! Thank you for everything!
read more
03/10/2024
media thumbnail 0
Lauren Kume Avatar
Lauren Kume
Working with Lauren Davie to sell our home was a seamless experience. Our situation was something that needed to be handled with professionalism and great care, and she was outstanding with both. She provided great data for comps, got us a great offer over our original plans, and ensured that all communication was timely and done right. Thank you, Lauren for being such an inclusive; knowledgeable; and most importantly kind real estate professional. The best part: we trusted her. Thank you again!
read more
03/10/2024
Brianna Couto Avatar
Brianna Couto
We had a first class experience working with Rob, Erin and the team at New Albany Realty from start to finish. They were able to ensure a seamless process on the sale of our current home and purchase of our next home in a competitive market. They truly made us feel like a priority and kept us informed every step along the way. We can’t recommend them enough!
read more
01/10/2024
Gregg Gibson Avatar
Gregg Gibson
With regard to Lauren Davie, Renee and I wanted to take a moment to express my deep appreciation for Lauren's outstanding work through the purchase of our home. Lauren's professionalism, knowledge, and "can do" attitude made the entire process smooth and low stress. From start to finish, Lauren went above and beyond to ensure our every concern was addressed, in a timely and mutually agreed upon way. We highly recommend working with Lauren and the Thomas Riddle Group to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you for your exceptional work Lauren.
read more
01/10/2024
Jeanine Gault Avatar
Jeanine Gault
BELATED THANK YOU to realtor Natasha Petroff for a number of things. I was moving over an hour away, and Natasha hooked me up with such great people that made my home buying process quick and easy, by involving K&J Inspections and Gerber Group. She checked off all boxes in my offer in March 2024 to get me a house in the area I needed in such a tough and limited inventory market in Grove City. She didn't hesitate to jump in to keep things moving when I couldn't physically be there. Also thank you Scott for being there for my final walk through. And thanks for the Thomas the Truck offering which I've used once so far! Even after the purchase I had a need to connect with previous owners with a maintenance issue who got me connected to the right people to avoid a tech repair bill. Grateful to all of the team involved - there is no way I would have had this success as a single mother with a quick close if I didn't have you. I hated the world in my season but you kept everything so positive so that I could work up some Joy again. Your service is stellar - Continued blessings to your group!!
read more
29/09/2024
Julie Cripps Avatar
Julie Cripps
Fabulous experience with the entire Thomas Riddle team, and especially agent extraordinaire Erin Spalding! We both sold and bought with Erin and she really came through in every possible aspect. We had several curve balls that came up during the sale of our home. I can't say enough how comforting it was to have an agent that we trusted with such an important transition period in our lives - she handled everything with professionalism, ease, and her experience really shined through. She really did go above and beyond!! We highly recommend Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and Erin, and would trust her again and again with any future real estate transactions. New Albany is a unique market and you want a firm and agent who know the area and know how to navigate this roller coaster of a market. You will be in good hands with them!
read more
27/09/2024
Alex Horn Avatar
Alex Horn
Kandis Hall was amazing to work with. She listened to our wants and found an off-market listing that checked all the boxes. We were so happy to work with a realtor that is well connected in the New Albany area and look forward to working with her to sell our current home!
read more
07/09/2024
  • 1
  • 2
  • 24
  • >

About Thomas|Riddle Real Estate Group

Expertise that puts you first.

Welcome to Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group, your premier choice for real estate services in Central Ohio. Established in 1998 by Kate and Tony Thomas and based in New Albany, Ohio, our team has been a trusted presence in the local market for over two decades. With a track record of success that includes over 2,000 homes sold and a remarkable $1 billion in total volume, we are proud to be a leading force in the real estate landscape. As a cornerstone of New Albany Realty, we are deeply ingrained in the community, offering unparalleled insight into the local market. We have also established ourselves as leaders in the real estate industry, consistently ranking among the Top 3 selling teams in all of Central Ohio. Our commitment to excellence has made us the go-to resource for all your real estate needs in New Albany and beyond.