Natasha Petroff

REALTOR®

Hello! I am Natasha Petroff. I pride myself on providing exceptional customer service, attentive communication, and focus on nuanced details. My goal is to blend my passion for people with the high professional standards of the Thomas Riddle team. Whether I am representing first time home buyers, or seasoned investors, I strive to make the real estate transaction as smooth and as stress free as possible; centrally focused on achieving my client’s goals. The greatest compliment is personal referrals and repeat clients. Fortunately, I have frequently been blessed by both. Outside of real estate, my focus is my family. Although my husband and I are both originally from the eastside suburbs of Cleveland, we both moved to Columbus to attend grad school at The Ohio State University. In 2010 we moved to New Albany to raise our family. We have three daughters, all of whom attend New Albany Plain Local schools. While most of our free time is spent on the sidelines coaching and cheering our daughters in travel basketball, lacrosse, swim & dive, and golf, when we do get an occasional moment, we very much enjoy spending time outdoors with friends and family playing various racquet sports.

What My Clients Say

Jong Huhl Avatar
Jong H.
Initially we were not sure which realty company and/or agent in helping us to sell our home. After all that is a lot of commission to pay out living in such a high demand area. Boy did we learn that the New Albany Realty team of Natasha and Rob was more that worth having on my team. There were 2 major reasons why we are not sure we would have made it through this process without them. First, due to the time of the year and our flexibility the team advised us on "presale" process which may help us in getting best value for our home. Secondly, the team guided me through the whole process through the sale and really showed their true value when we encountered a few issues along the way that without their assistance not sure we would have been able to sell the home. Thank you Natasha and Rob for all your help in making this possible !!
read more
4/08/2025
Jason Kim Avatar
Jason K.
I was a first time buyer and new to the Columbus area and I had the privilege working with Natasha from New Albany Realty. Luckily I ran into her during an open house I attended and glad I did. Natasha went above and beyond helping me throughout the process from start to end, making my first time buying experience a pleasant one. She was able to accommodate last minute showings, provided honest opinions, and provided me with trustworthy industry professionals. I will definitely reach out to New Albany Realty and Natasha for future needs.
read more
3/02/2025
Jeanine Gault Avatar
Jeanine G.
BELATED THANK YOU to realtor Natasha Petroff for a number of things. I was moving over an hour away, and Natasha hooked me up with such great people that made my home buying process quick and easy, by involving K&J Inspections and Gerber Group. She checked off all boxes in my offer in March 2024 to get me a house in the area I needed in such a tough and limited inventory market in Grove City. She didn't hesitate to jump in to keep things moving when I couldn't physically be there. Also thank you Scott for being there for my final walk through. And thanks for the Thomas the Truck offering which I've used once so far! Even after the purchase I had a need to connect with previous owners with a maintenance issue who got me connected to the right people to avoid a tech repair bill. Grateful to all of the team involved - there is no way I would have had this success as a single mother with a quick close if I didn't have you. I hated the world in my season but you kept everything so positive so that I could work up some Joy again. Your service is stellar - Continued blessings to your group!!
read more
9/29/2024
Suah Hwang Avatar
Suah H.
All around very positive experience! Natasha was so professional and hands-on. We only have great things to say with our experience. Highly recommend.
read more
4/22/2024
Caitlin Cipriano Avatar
Caitlin C.
Natasha made our first time buying a home amazing! Her patience, compassion, and diligence truly made a difference in our home buying experience. She worked day and night to find our perfect home. Thanks Natasha -Cait and Antonio
read more
4/02/2024