M. Scott Siebenaler

As a first-time seller, finding a trustworthy realtor can be challenging. Scott Siebenaler stood out with his transparency and honest approach, avoiding any overselling. I’m extremely pleased with the services he provided, making the selling process seamless. Highly recommend!

BELATED THANK YOU to realtor Natasha Petroff for a number of things. I was moving over an hour away, and Natasha hooked me up with such great people that made my home buying process quick and easy, by involving K&J Inspections and Gerber Group. She checked off all boxes in my offer in March 2024 to get me a house in the area I needed in such a tough and limited inventory market in Grove City. She didn't hesitate to jump in to keep things moving when I couldn't physically be there. Also thank you Scott for being there for my final walk through. And thanks for the Thomas the Truck offering which I've used once so far! Even after the purchase I had a need to connect with previous owners with a maintenance issue who got me connected to the right people to avoid a tech repair bill. Grateful to all of the team involved - there is no way I would have had this success as a single mother with a quick close if I didn't have you. I hated the world in my season but you kept everything so positive so that I could work up some Joy again. Your service is stellar - Continued blessings to your group!!

Incredible firm to guide my wife and I on our first time home buying experience. Scott S. was amazing to work with and was always proactive and available at the drop of a hat to take us on showings. Thomas | Riddle Real Estate Group - New Albany Reality was and remains the only logical selection in my opinion if you want to get in the New Albany Market. A+.

I recently purchased a home using Thomas Riddle with Scott Siebenhaler as my realtor. Scott was professional and creative with negotiating the close on the home. The support staff (Heather Graham)-kept me informed up until my move in date of any and all things needed to move in. I highly recommend Thomas Riddle and Scott specifically. From close to move in was less than 30 days!!

We had a wonderful experience selling our home and buying a new one with the Thomas Riddle group! They were very organized and went above and beyond to help us during our move. They even sent us reminders about switching utilities, including phone numbers to call, a helpful moving checklist, and they have a complimentary box truck (Thomas the Truck) that we got to use for our move. Special shout out to our agent, Scott Siebenaler, for being so on top of things. Thanks for everything!

Scott was a wonderful agent to work with. He did so many things, going to town hall meetings and market evaluations to assess the value of my moms home. Due to mom having COPD she was unable to make multiple trips outside of the home. Scott brought everything to her. I could not have asked for better treatment or care in such an emotional time.

I had an excellent first time home buying experience with Scott and Erin! Everyone on the team is personable, responsive, and knowledgeable. I highly recommend.

Excellent experience working with Scott Siebenaler. He made the process seamless, enjoyable, and efficient. I had many questions as a first time home buyer, Scott was more than willing to help any time I needed guidance. I will definitely be recommending Scott to friends and family!

We have had a wonderful experience working with Scott Siebenaler. He is easy to work with, full of knowledge and has great passion in his work. He takes great care with all your questions and makes sure you understand everything going on with your listing. We highly recommend you contact Scott if you are buying a new home or selling your home.