M. Scott Siebenaler, REALTOR®

M. Scott Siebenaler


Born and raised in a small town in Northwest Ohio, Scott realized early on the value of hard work, community, and helping others. After graduating The Ohio State University, Scott began an exciting career with a locally based fashion retailer, sharpening his communication and negotiation skills. He and his wife, Kelly, moved to New Albany in 2003 to raise their two children Payton and Michael.

Being able to combine his small-town values, business acumen and being a part of the New Albany community led him to Thomas | Riddle. As your real estate agent, he is prepared to offer his clients a well-rounded perspective on the buying and selling process. Scott prides himself on commitment to customer service, while helping his clients achieve their goals.

Scott is also an avid cyclist and a deeply passionate member of the Pelotonia community, riding every year since the inaugural 2009 event.

What My Clients Say

Mvanstrat Avatar
Incredible firm to guide my wife and I on our first time home buying experience. Scott S. was amazing to work with and was always proactive and available at the drop of a hat to take us on showings. Thomas | Riddle Real Estate Group - New Albany Reality was and remains the only logical selection in my opinion if you want to get in the New Albany Market. A+.
read more
Jim Tyznik Avatar
Jim T.
I recently purchased a home using Thomas Riddle with Scott Siebenhaler as my realtor. Scott was professional and creative with negotiating the close on the home. The support staff (Heather Graham)-kept me informed up until my move in date of any and all things needed to move in. I highly recommend Thomas Riddle and Scott specifically. From close to move in was less than 30 days!!
read more
Alyssa Workman Avatar
Alyssa W.
We had a wonderful experience selling our home and buying a new one with the Thomas Riddle group! They were very organized and went above and beyond to help us during our move. They even sent us reminders about switching utilities, including phone numbers to call, a helpful moving checklist, and they have a complimentary box truck (Thomas the Truck) that we got to use for our move. Special shout out to our agent, Scott Siebenaler, for being so on top of things. Thanks for everything!
read more
Lori Beach Avatar
Lori B.
Scott was a wonderful agent to work with. He did so many things, going to town hall meetings and market evaluations to assess the value of my moms home. Due to mom having COPD she was unable to make multiple trips outside of the home. Scott brought everything to her. I could not have asked for better treatment or care in such an emotional time.
read more
Bennett Lowery Avatar
Bennett L.
I had an excellent first time home buying experience with Scott and Erin! Everyone on the team is personable, responsive, and knowledgeable. I highly recommend.
read more
Rebecca Windham Avatar
Rebecca W.
Excellent experience working with Scott Siebenaler. He made the process seamless, enjoyable, and efficient. I had many questions as a first time home buyer, Scott was more than willing to help any time I needed guidance. I will definitely be recommending Scott to friends and family!
read more
Ann Davis Avatar
Ann D.
We have had a wonderful experience working with Scott Siebenaler. He is easy to work with, full of knowledge and has great passion in his work. He takes great care with all your questions and makes sure you understand everything going on with your listing. We highly recommend you contact Scott if you are buying a new home or selling your home.
read more
Ben Roth Avatar
Ben R.
Scott did a great job listing both of our homes. He is very involved in the entire process and even staged the condo. Always promptly returned calls and would definitely use in the future!
read more
Deepali Tukaye Avatar
Deepali T.
Scott Siebenaler helped us in our home buying process. He is professional, diligent and prompt. He helped us through every step till closing and after. We give him our highest recommendation.
read more