About Scott

Born and raised in the small town in Northwest Ohio, Scott realized early on the value of hard work, community and helping others. After graduating The Ohio State University, Scott began an exciting career with a locally based fashion retailer, sharpening his communication and negotiation skills. He and his wife, Kelly, moved to New Albany in 2003 to raise their two children Payton and Michael.

Being able to combine his small-town values, business acumen and being a part of the New Albany community led him to Thomas | Riddle. As your real estate agent, he is prepared to offer his clients a well-rounded perspective to the buying and selling process. Scott prides himself on commitment to customer service, while helping his clients achieve their goals.

Scott is also an avid cyclist and a deeply passionate member of the Pelotonia community, riding every year since the inaugural 2009 event.

What My Clients Say

Ben Roth Avatar
Ben R.
Scott did a great job listing both of our homes. He is very involved in the entire process and even staged the condo. Always promptly returned calls and would definitely... read more
Deepali Tukaye Avatar
Deepali T.
Scott Siebenaler helped us in our home buying process. He is professional, diligent and prompt. He helped us through every step till closing and after. We give him our... read more
Azzam Mahmood Avatar
Azzam M.
My wife and I started our home search back in February and we were completely shocked at how tough it was as first time home buyers. One of my coworkers... read more
Patricia Purcell Avatar
Patricia P.
I worked with Scott on two separate transactions in just 4 short weeks. His vast market knowledge allowed me to both buy and sell in this highly competitive market.... read more
sam djafari Avatar
sam d.
I was a first time home buyer who was investing out of state. I worked with Scott and he made buying a house a such a breeze! He was professional... read more
Daphinie Saas Avatar
Daphinie S.
Scott Siebenaler is THE best. His unmatched knowledge of the market and subsequent strategy is world class. We consider ourselves lucky to have had the privilege of working with him... read more
Matt Crawford Avatar
Matt C.
Unbelievably good experience all the way around. We were in the market for purchasing a home and also selling our previous home once we purchased a new one. We worked... read more
Karen Jobson Avatar
Karen J.
I had the best experience recently with Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and specifically, their agent, Scott Siebenaler. He made the process so easy and handled the sale of... read more
Matthew Smith Avatar
Matthew S.
Scott and the Thomas Riddle team were excellent. The entire practice was very organized and professional throughout our buying process. They were able to help out with every aspect of... read more

Get in Touch

Preferred Professionals

I work with the same trusted people time and time again because I know they do quality work for great prices.

Home Lending

NFM Lending, The Daniel Sa Team
Nick Cannon

Flagstar Bank
Ashelia Wright

Home Inspectors

HomeTeam Inspection Service


614 Exteriors
Keith Staschke


America’s Floor Source
Joel Wood


The Waterworks


Shane Neff | Individual Contractor

Compare listings


Get Started With A Free, No-Obligation, Market Analysis.

As full-time and fully dedicated real estate agents, our sole focus will be on your sale and your happiness. We will always be a call, email, or text away to advise you as needed.

Get Your Updated Home Value

Where should we send your updated home value?

Anything else we should know?

Note: Please be assured we will use this information only to send you the information you have requested and we will never share or rent your contact information with any other party. By giving us your name and email address, you are giving Thomas|Riddle Real Estate Group permission to contact you.