Scott Siebenaler
Real Estate Consultant
Born and raised in the small town in Northwest Ohio, Scott realized early on the value of hard work, community and helping others. After graduating The Ohio State University, Scott began an exciting career with a locally based fashion retailer, sharpening his communication and negotiation skills. He and his wife, Kelly, moved to New Albany in 2003 to raise their two children Payton and Michael.
Being able to combine his small-town values, business acumen and being a part of the New Albany community led him to Thomas | Riddle. As your real estate agent, he is prepared to offer his clients a well-rounded perspective to the buying and selling process. Scott prides himself on commitment to customer service, while helping his clients achieve their goals.
Scott is also an avid cyclist and a deeply passionate member of the Pelotonia community, riding every year since the inaugural 2009 event.
Being able to combine his small-town values, business acumen and being a part of the New Albany community led him to Thomas | Riddle. As your real estate agent, he is prepared to offer his clients a well-rounded perspective to the buying and selling process. Scott prides himself on commitment to customer service, while helping his clients achieve their goals.
Scott is also an avid cyclist and a deeply passionate member of the Pelotonia community, riding every year since the inaugural 2009 event.
What Our Clients Say
Erin Walther
17:25 26 Nov 21
Rob and the rest of the team at Thomas | Riddle helped us find our perfect home a few years ago.... They guided us through the process with fabulous advice and support. Even though we are currently not in the market for a new house, Rob has still been a invaluable resource with other various home projects - best strategies when finishing the basement, patio projects, etc. Thanks, Rob!read more
Karen Jobson
01:32 26 Nov 21
I had the best experience recently with Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and specifically, their... agent, Scott Siebenaler. He made the process so easy and handled the sale of my house with such professionalism and care. He was always one step ahead and always provided me with clear, concise information. I would highly recommend Scott and the entire Thomas Riddle team!read more
Melissa Stall
21:46 25 Nov 21
Rob and his team are knowledgeable, professional and generous with their time. They believe in the... value of relationships and understand that trust forms the basis for any successful business. Rob continues to be a friend and still provides counsel and advice any time we have a need. We highly recommend Thomas | Riddle Real Estate.read more
Jon Roell
13:56 11 Oct 21
Kandis Hall was our real estate consultant and she was incredibly professional, friendly and... efficient. She would never hesitate to return a text or answer a call. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to buy or sell a houseread more
Michael Lisko
20:53 07 Sep 21
My wife and I recently sold a property we owned in Gahanna with Rob and his team. Rob was always... the epitome of professionalism and market and product knowledge. We couldn't have been in better hands trying to navigate the market or all the ins and outs of trying to sell a home. We would highly recommend Thomas / Riddle Real Estate Group to anyone selling a home. Rob is without a doubt the best realtor we have ever worked with.read more
Jennie Norris
13:13 27 Aug 21
We recently worked with Erin from the Thomas Riddle group on a land purchase in NA. We couldn’t... have been in better hands. This wasn’t a straight forward purchase but with her knowledge and attention to detail we felt confident every step of the way. We were able to get our dream lot, UNDER list price, and with plenty of time to do due diligence. We are so thankful for Erin and her team. If you are looking to purchase in this crazy market, I highly recommend Erin!read more
Aleksandr Bevz
15:58 11 Aug 21
The Thomas Riddle real estate team did an amazing job to find us the perfect home. Our agent Scott... Siebenaler went above and beyond and we highly recommend him to friends and family. Scott acted as a mentor to us and taught us a lot about the home buying process since this is our first time buying a house and we had minimal knowledge of how it all works. With Scott’s help and knowledge we found the perfect home and are very happy with it. Scott was always available and very responsive if we had any questions and we felt very confident having him as our agent. Thank you very much Scott and the Thomas Riddle team. You guys are the best and we will definitely reach out the next time we are in the market for a home.read more
Michael Silverstein
02:20 23 Jul 21
Last fall, my wife and I found ourselves very unexpectedly having our rental sold out from under us... and had been given 60 days’ notice to leave. Knowing we wanted to be in the New Albany area, a quick Google search took us to Rob and his team. I left a message for Rob on a Sunday thinking we might get a call back early the next week and almost immediately got a call back from Rob himself who, upon hearing about our crazy timeline, jumped into action. From being a lifelong expert on the New Albany area, an incredibly skilled and knowledgeable realtor, and an extremely warm, genuine, and honest person, Rob was an absolute lifesaver and gave us the best experience we could’ve ever hoped for in partnering with a realtor. He took the time to give us a tour and rundown of all the NA neighborhoods, moved extremely quickly to show us houses coming up on the market, and was very communicative throughout the process. We were so grateful to Rob for all the time and energy he put into ensuring that not only would we have a place to live by the time we had to be out of our rental, but also for the deep care and concern he showed us throughout our first home-buying process.read more
Justin Flowers
12:29 18 Jul 21
Rob and the entire team at Thomas | Riddle Real Estate Group were truly amazing in helping us to... find the perfect home for our family’s next chapter! Rob patiently worked with us for 2 years to find us the right home for our needs. He and the team are extremely experienced and knowledgeable in the New Albany real estate market, being aware of homes coming to market before others - which has been critically important for Buyers in the current market conditions. From the start of our search to the closing, Rob and his team were incredibly attentive to our needs. We would highly recommend Thomas | Riddle Real Estate Group to anyone considering a move into (or out of) the area.read more
Kristin Clegg
18:34 05 Jul 21
Tracy was wonderful, courteous, professional and knowledgeable. She knew exactly what we were... looking for. She helped us from out-of-state and was always available to answer questions and calls. She took us to numerous places until we found our home. We highly recommend Tracy as your realtor and if ever needed we would use her again.read more
George Proicou
18:02 29 Jun 21
I have worked with Rob and his team since 2017 and have experienced nothing but professional... dedicated service. Rob is very knowledgeable in real estate and helped broker the favorable sale of two of our properties. Rob and his team were present through the whole process and made the transaction as simple and easy as possible. We will use Thomas|Riddle again for our next real estate deal!read more
Dean Haldeman
15:39 21 Jun 21
Rob helped us through several transactions, and was instrumental in obtaining our dream property in... New Albany. Very professional, responsive, and caring. He continues to look out for our investing needs, and will always be a part of my team. I highly recommend Rob to anyone looking for a great realtor.read more
Nate Long
20:58 18 Jun 21
I can't speak highly enough of Rob Riddle and his team. My wife and I were house shopping from... Virginia and it was proving very difficult to find a house because they were gone before we had a chance to see them in person. Rob was very patient and helped guide us to New Albany where we absolutely love our neighborhood! We couldn't have asked for a better experience and Rob and his wife Johnna are now good friends of ours! The Riddle Real Estate Group are genuine people who care about you and your happiness - not just your business. Thanks Rob!!read more
Chip Sergakis
18:18 15 Jun 21
Everyone I have worked with at this Agency has been fantastic! First class professionalism through... and through. Especially Rob and Dave!! I sent Rob my lengthy list of requirements and he continually updated on any new product coming available or product already on the market. If you are looking for a home in the New Albany area look no further! Rob has got you covered.read more
Jared Mutchler
19:12 14 Jun 21
Rob was great to work with both times we worked with him. He helped us struggle to find our first... house and stuck with us for our second. He was happy to show us houses when we could work in the time and had great advice throughout. He connected us with what we needed when we needed it. The whole team was helpful along every step along the way.read more
Joshua Hall
17:50 14 Jun 21
Rob is a first class realtor. He was knowledgeable, patient and extremely helpful when purchasing... our home. He negotiated a tremendous price and made the process quite simple. I would absolutely recommend!read more
Amanda Ray
11:35 05 May 21
*HIGHLY RECOMMEND* We would not have been able to close on our dream home with out Rob. He is the... most knowledgeable realator we have ever worked with. He answered our calls/texts immediately. Thank you so much to the entire team that helped us buy/sell. You guys are amazing.read more
Nancy Roberts
01:43 05 May 21
We worked with Tracey West on the recent purchase of our home in Johnstown. We met Tracey at an... open house a few years ago when we just started looking. Tracey kept in touch with us occasionally by sending houses she thought would fit our criteria.
When we found a house recently that we liked, we knew we would have to move fast in this market. Tracey was super-responsive and always got back to us quickly. She is fun and not at all pushy in the sales process. We are so happy with our new home and thank Tracey for all she did in the process!read more
Lauren Godwin
22:02 19 Mar 21
We have worked with Andrea twice at Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and each time she has done a... fantastic job. She stays on top of it and was very communicative throughout the entire process. I would totally recommend her to future clients.read more
Danyelle Hoschar
01:59 12 Mar 21
This was our first home buying experience, working with Erin Spalding and the the team at Thomas... Riddle was the best decision we could have made. Erin is AMAZING to wok with. She and the team made the process easy and walked us through every step letting us know what to expect as we moved through every step. If we ever buy or sell again they will my first call!read more
Travis Baldwin
21:47 28 Jan 21
Highly Recommend!!! We had the best experience with Rob Riddle and Team. Rob and the Team were... outstanding to work with - communication and industry knowledge was superb, making the home buying/selling process for my family an enjoyable one. There is no doubt we will be using them again for all of our future real estate endeavors. Oh and Thomas the Truck what an awesome perk for their clients! Eliminated the hassle of renting a truck and moving equipment saving both time and money.
Travis Baldwinread more