1251 Lancaster Avenue, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

New Listing
$285,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 4 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 1,577 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 14,375 Status: Coming Soon
Current Price: $285,000 List Date: 1/21/2026 Last Modified: 1/21/2026

Description

Welcome home to the perfect blend of historic charm and modern comfort in this beautiful property just moments from the heart of Uptown Reynoldsburg. Inside, you'll find thoughtful updates paired with timeless character, starting with the inviting first floor featuring arched doorways, new lighting, LVP flooring, and fresh paint throughout. The beautifully updated kitchen features granite counters, tiled backsplash, crisp white cabinets, and SS appliances. The spacious dining room flows to a warm, welcoming living room anchored by a decorative fireplace with beautiful wood surround. Upstairs, the second floor hosts three charming and beautifully finished bedrooms, a large, updated full bath, and heirloom hallway built-ins. Hardwood floors add richness and warmth throughout this level. The third floor provides a versatile fourth bedroom complete with charming built-ins and exposed brick, making it a perfect retreat, guest space, or creative studio. The basement adds even more potential with a second decorative fireplace and a convenient half bath—ideal for future finishing or for use as generous storage. A bright 3-season room offers serene views of the expansive backyard—lined by the peaceful Blacklick Creek and backing to the 26 acre John F Kennedy Park complete with baseball fields, tennis courts, playground, picnic facilities, and trail that connects with Huber Park. With convenient location just feet from the vibrant Uptown Reynoldsburg, a picturesque natural setting, and a home full of character and updates, this property is truly one-of-a-kind.

Supplements: ********

More Information MLS# 226002024

Location & Property Info

List Price/SqFt: 180.72 Mid/High Rise: No City (Mailing Addr): Reynoldsburg Corp LimitPerAuditor: Reynoldsburg New Construction: No

Office/Contract Info

Active on MLS: 2026-01-23

General Property Info

Baths F.H: 1.1 Manufactured Housing Y/N: No Built Prior to 1978: Yes SqFt Documented: 1577 Documented SqFt Source: Realist ATFLS Source: Realist Lot Size (Side): 402 HOA/COA Y/N: No Comm Dev Chrg: No Bedrooms: 4 Total Baths: 2 Full Baths: 1 Half Baths: 1 Garage/EnclosdSpaces: 1 Year Built: 1943 SqFt ATFLS: 1577 Acreage: 0.33

Tax Info

Mult Parcels/Sch Dis: No Tax Abatement: No Taxes (Yrly): 3823 Parcel #: 060-000240 Tax Year: 2024

Remarks & Misc

Property Description: Welcome home to the perfect blend of historic charm and modern comfort in this beautiful property just moments from the heart of Uptown Reynoldsburg. Inside, you'll find thoughtful updates paired with timeless character, starting with the inviting first floor featuring arched doorways, new lighting, LVP flooring, and fresh paint throughout. The beautifully updated kitchen features granite counters, tiled backsplash, crisp white cabinets, and SS appliances. The spacious dining room flows to a warm, welcoming living room anchored by a decorative fireplace with beautiful wood surround. Upstairs, the second floor hosts three charming and beautifully finished bedrooms, a large, updated full bath, and heirloom hallway built-ins. Hardwood floors add richness and warmth throughout this level. The third floor provides a versatile fourth bedroom complete with charming built-ins and exposed brick, making it a perfect retreat, guest space, or creative studio. The basement adds even more potential with a second decorative fireplace and a convenient half bath—ideal for future finishing or for use as generous storage. A bright 3-season room offers serene views of the expansive backyard—lined by the peaceful Blacklick Creek and backing to the 26 acre John F Kennedy Park complete with baseball fields, tennis courts, playground, picnic facilities, and trail that connects with Huber Park. With convenient location just feet from the vibrant Uptown Reynoldsburg, a picturesque natural setting, and a home full of character and updates, this property is truly one-of-a-kind.

Addl Acceptance Cond

None Known: 1

Levels

Three: 1

Architectural Style

Craftsman: 1

Common Walls

No Common Walls: 1

Bedroom Level

Beds UP2: 1 Beds UP1: 3

Full Baths Level

Full Baths UP1: 1

Half Baths Level

Half Bath Down1: 1

Living Room Level

Living R Entry Level: 1

Parking Features

Detached Garage: 1 Tandem: 1

Water Source

Public: 1

Sewer

Public Sewer: 1

Basement

Basement Y/N: Yes

Dining Room Level

Dining Entry Level: 1

Basement Description

Full: 1

Foundation

Block: 1

Eating Space Level

Eating S Entry Level: 1

Lot Characteristics

Stream On Lot: 1

Rooms

LL Laundry: 1 3-Season Room: 1 Dining Room: 1 Eat Space/Kit: 1 Living Room: 1

Fireplace

Total Fireplaces: 2 Two: 1 Decorative: 1

Auction Info

Auction/Online Bidding Y/N: No

Heating

Boiler: 1 Forced Air: 1 Gas: 1

New Financing

Conventional: 1

Air Conditioning

Central Air: 1

Utility Space Level

Utility Down1: 1

Interior Flooring

Laminate: 1 Wood: 1

Interior Amenities

Dishwasher: 1 Gas Range: 1 Microwave: 1 Refrigerator: 1

Accessible Features

Accessible Features - Form Required: No

Patio and Porch Features

Porch: 1

Other Structures

Outbuilding: 1

Exterior

Vinyl Siding: 1

MLS Primary PhotoSrc

Realtor Provided: 1

Printing Services

No Printing Services: 1

Accessory Dwelling Unit

Existing Accessory Dwelling Unit: No

Leased Items Y/N

Leased Items: No

Green Features

Green Features Y/N - Form Required: No

Location Property Info

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence Original List Price: 285000 List Price: $285,000 Street #: 1251 Street Name: Lancaster Street Suffix: Avenue County: Franklin State: OH Zip Code: 43068 School District: REYNOLDSBURG CSD 2509 FRA CO. Township: Truro Subdiv/Cmplx/Comm: Uptown Reynoldsburg

OfficeContract Info

Status: Coming Soon MLS Entry Date: 2026-01-21

Remarks Misc

Directions: 40 to Lancaster Ave, 1251 will be on the left

Property Features

Levels: Three Architectural Style: Craftsman Common Walls: No Common Walls Addl Acceptance Cond: None Known Parking Features: Detached Garage; Tandem Basement Description: Full Foundation: Block Exterior: Vinyl Siding Rooms: LL Laundry; 3-Season Room; Dining Room; Eat Space/Kit; Living Room Fireplace: Two; Decorative Heating: Boiler; Forced Air; Gas Air Conditioning: Central Air Interior Flooring: Laminate; Wood Sewer: Public Sewer Water Source: Public Interior Amenities: Dishwasher; Gas Range; Microwave; Refrigerator Patio and Porch Features: Porch Other Structures: Outbuilding New Financing: Conventional Lot Characteristics: Stream On Lot MLS Primary PhotoSrc: Realtor Provided Printing Services: No Printing Services
Listing Office: Red 1 Realty
Listing Agent: Michelle R Brooks
Last Updated: January - 21 - 2026
The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity/IDX of Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service.Information provided is thought to be reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate; you are advised to verify facts that are important to you. No warranties, expressed or implied, are provided for the data herein, or for their use or interpretation by the user. Columbus Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service does not create, control or review the property data displayed herein and take no responsibility for the content of such records. Federal law prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin in the sale, rental or financing of housing. Copyright 2025 Columbus Board of Realtors. All rights reserved.